Many critics are slamming the new
movie production of Les Miserables, based on the Broadway musical taken
from Victor Hugo’s classic novel. Having read some of these negative reviews, I
can only be saddened. These people simply don’t understand. They go on and on
about the movie’s imperfections, some legitimate, some, in my opinion, totally
untrue. In focusing on the flaws in the film itself, they totally miss the
point. Or maybe they do get the point, and it makes them angry because
they want to deny its truth: there are such things as forgiveness,
redemption, and self-sacrifice. Victor Hugo knew this, and wrote about it, as
my husband puts it, “with a sledgehammer.” He tackled the notion of man’s inhumanity
to man with a grim and gritty sense of realism, unmatched by few save perhaps Mark Twain, Charles Dickens, and Harper Lee.
The story of Jean Valjean, sent
to prison for stealing a loaf of bread to feed his starving family, is, at its
core, a very simple one. The novel itself is nearly 1500 pages long, but about
a third of it is exposition, attempting to help the reader understand the
context and setting and focusing on the political aspects of the story as well
as the history of France. It is the story, however, that matters. It is a love
story. The love of parents for their children, the love of friends for one
another, the love between husbands and wives, the love of God for humanity-it
is all there, presented with heart-rending beauty and complete honesty. Jean
Valjean’s redemption following a simple act of human kindness gives us pause. If
mankind and mercy are truly our business, then why aren’t we doing more?
These thoughts make people
uncomfortable, and that may be why the critics are not getting it. They don’t
want to. It is impossible to truly do good without God, no matter how hard we
strive, on our own, to “be good”. Javert, the antagonist of the story, is a
pathetic figure despite his self-righteousness and relentless pursuit of
Valjean. In bondage to law and order,
Javert has convinced himself that because he is “good” and Valjean is “bad”,
his cause must be just and that the only “right” thing to do is capture
Valjean. This inner conflict eventually drives Javert to suicide. It is easy for us to simply dismiss Javert as
evil-but is he? Or is he merely a picture of the way we ourselves tend to live?
Yes, it causes great discomfort
indeed to examine ourselves and consider how many we may have turned away
because they were labeled as worthless, hopeless, beyond redemption. For all
the time we spend mocking a Britney Spears or a Charlie Sheen-would that time
not be better spent in actually praying for them?
Their falls from grace-which are not truly falls from Grace, after all,
because God still loves them-make us feel so much better about ourselves, don’t
they? We can say, “Well, at least I’ve never done THAT.” Is that so much to
brag about? Maybe we haven’t done “that”,
but we’ve certainly done plenty-and, even worse, failed to do what we really
ought to do. But we forget about that, and watch a film like Les
Miserables and try to figure out who the good guys and bad guys are. We
tell ourselves that the priest would never really protect a Jean Valjean, would
never give him the stolen silverware and hand him the candlesticks as well.
That’s just a fantasy. But wait-isn’t there something in the Bible about if a
man takes your shirt, you are to give him your cloak as well? And if that was
an impossibility, would Jesus have told us to do it?
I noticed that a lot of people
were crying at the end of Les Miserables. I myself started weeping when
Jean Valjean was given the candlesticks, and never really stopped until I was
almost home from the theatre. It wasn’t just sniffles, either-by the end of the
movie, tears were rolling down my face at a ridiculous rate. But for whom, or
what, was I crying? Why did my chest hurt, why did I feel as if I couldn’t
breathe, why could I not even speak for a full fifteen minutes after the movie
ended? Yes, it was horribly sad,
possibly even leaning toward melodrama. It was beautiful and poetic . The
characters were wonderfully realized. Fantine’s awful situation, the rescue of
Cosette by Valjean, the suicide of Javert, the death of Valjean, the love that
existed among the characters-all of this, and more, stirred emotion and opened
the floodgates. But there was Something Else. Something bigger.
The story of Les Miserables ,
the title of which can be translated as The Wretched, The Victims, The
Poor Ones, or The Miserable, is the story of all of us. It is a
story of loss and pain and longing for “a castle on a cloud”- a better place, a
true home, somewhere to belong. It is a story of dreams destroyed, of
bitterness and emptiness, of the utter despair people sometimes feel. But it is
also a story of hope. It is a story that helps us understand the truth that to
love someone is to see the face of God. Fantine, depite her outcast and
miserable state, had Something-because she loved Cosette. When we reach out our
hand to help a person in need, when we call someone “brother” and show them the
respect and dignity to which every God-breathed soul is entitled, we see His
face-and, hopefully, we acknowledge our own brokenness and wretchedness and
very great need for the Love that transcends our humanity.
Let us be good to each other-and
see the face of God.
“Ecclesiastes names thee
Almighty, the Maccabees name thee Creator, the Epistle to the Ephesians names
thee Liberty, Baruch names thee Immensity, the Psalms name thee Wisdom and
Truth, John names thee Light, the Book of Kings names thee Lord, Exodus names thee
Providence, Leviticus Sanctity, Esdras Justice, creation names thee God, man
names thee Father; but Solomon names thee Compassion, which is the most
beautiful of all thy names.”
― Victor Hugo, Les Misérables
― Victor Hugo, Les Misérables
Most excellently written!!! Thank you so much for this article which I am sharing everywhere. I have always loved the story Les Miserables. My previous favorite of the productions done was the 1939 movie with Charles Laughton, but I thought the current movie which we just saw was really well done. I look forward to following your blog. Thank you.
ReplyDelete